Recital 19, Decision_act (EU) 2004/103

In forcesince 30 Jan 2002

The Commission cannot share Tetra's view. The Prohibition Decision found serious and immediate competitive concerns. As set out in the Prohibition Decision, there are three core areas of horizontal overlap between the parties: low-capacity SBM machines; barrier technology; and aseptic PET filling machines. In these areas the parties are direct competitors. The Prohibition Decision also found significant vertical links between the parties as Sidel is a supplier of SBM machines and other PET equipment and, as considered in recital 38, Tetra is potentially a buyer of such equipment which it can use in its downstream converter activities. Tetra has not yet divested its SBM machine business or preforms business and, although it has expressed its desire to divest these businesses, there is no formally binding commitment to do so. In any event, even if such a divestiture took place, Tetra would retain significant activities in barrier technologies and PET aseptic filling equipment, key areas for the penetration of PET in the sensitive product markets where Sidel is a direct competitor. Despite Tetra's contention, there are therefore both horizontal and, potentially, vertical competitive relations between the two companies.