As far as the report drawn up by the consultant hired by the complainants is concerned, the Commission expert is of the opinion that the study is based to a large extent on a theoretical model, founded on working hypotheses, and hence remote from the specific case of SNCM. For this reason it was impossible for him to compare the figures given in the model with those of SNCM's accounts. This report does not therefore make it possible to conclude whether or not there was overcompensation. Indeed, a conclusion of this kind presupposes an examination of compensation paid compared with the real costs of SNCM in a given context. But this research had not been carried out. The author confined himself to showing that, under certain conditions and if certain working hypotheses were valid, a company entrusted with the management of a public service could make a profit.
Recital 93, Decision_act (EU) 2002/149
In forcesince 30 Oct 2001