No competing operator was able to fulfil the requirements of annual regularity and frequency of service provided for by the agreement scheme, neither for passenger nor for goods transport. Even the presence, since 1996, of a private operator on a limited number of lines and during a part of the year only has not been able to satisfy the public service requirements deemed necessary by the French public authorities. In this context, it must be noted that, within the framework of the implementation of Regulation (EEC) No 3577/92, the Commission considers it legitimate to impose obligations for a period covering both the low and the high season in order to avoid the risk of shipowners creaming off the market and who, operating only in the summer, would leave the operator in charge of the public service obligations with all of the non-profitable lines. Consequently, the Commission comes to the conclusion that the absence of competition observed by the French authorities in 1991 and 1996, when the two five-year agreements were concluded, justifies the need for providing a public service within the framework of an agreement scheme.
Recital 74, Decision_act (EU) 2002/149
In forcesince 30 Oct 2001