Exports and imports of the Community to/from third countries
(ECU million)
Year Exports EUR-12 Imports EUR-12 1985 41,2 21,5 1986 38,9 22,1 1987 38,3 25,2 1988 37,8 27,9
Where financial assistance from the State strengthens the position of certain enterprises compared with that of others competing with them in the Community, it must be deemed to affect those other enterprises.
Consequently, the aid which the Italian Government has granted to IOR affects trade between Member States and distorts or threatens to distort competition within the meaning of Article 92 (1).
VI
By not notifying the Commission, at the proposal stage, of its decision to grant aid to IOR, the Italian Government failed to fulfil its obligations pursuant to Article 93 (3).
The Commission - making use of a possibility given to it by Article 93 (2) and by the Court of Justice in its Judgment of 12 July 1973 in Case 70/72 (1), confirmed in its Judgment of 24 February 1987 in Case 310/85 (2) - can require Member States to recover aid granted without prior notification, where such aid is found to be incompatible with the common market, from the recipients thereof.
VII
The exceptions to the general incompatibility of the aid set out in Article 92 (2) are inapplicable in this case in view of the nature of the aid which is not directed towards attainment of that provision.