In reply to five additional questions put by the Commission by letter dated 11 October 1989, the Italian Government provided information by means of a telex message dated 19 December 1989. These questions concerned a payment of Lit 5 661 million by Sofin to IOR in 1987; the conditions on which Sofin had lent Lit 6 000 million to IOR; the conditions on which Sofin had remained a 50 % shareholder between 15 October 1986 and 15 March 1989; the financial details of the partial privatization in October 1986; other possible candidates for taking over IOR. Notably on the latter subject, additional information was provided by letter received on 12 June 1990 and in a bilateral meeting on 6 July 1990.
In the course of consulting other interested parties, observations were also submitted by Finalp, Sofin and IOR; none of them considered that the Italian Government's actions contained elements of State aid and they agreed with the Italian Government that, even if there were such aid elements, they would surely be compatible with the common market.
The Governments of three other Member States, namely Germany, Denmark and the Netherlands, submitted observations within the framework of the procedure supporting the Commission's decision to initiate the procedure.
All observations made by third parties were submitted to the Italian Government by letter dated 18 September 1989 inviting its comments. These comments were sent to the Commission by telex message dated 17 January 1990.
IV
The provision of funds to public enterprises by their shareholder may involve elements of State aid. In order to verify whether such a provision constitutes aid, it would in the first place be appropriate, ignoring any social elements or regional or sectoral policy, to consider whether under similar circumstances a private shareholder would go ahead with such a step on the basis of the same conditions in the light of expected profitability.
Regarding IOR the Commission notes that this company's accumulated losses amounted to Lit 43 700 million between 1982 and 1986, compared with a share capital of Lit 4 000 million.
It is the Commission's opinion that a private investor would not have paid almost eleven times his original investment in five years, in order to be able to dispose of half of the investment at its nominal price, as Sofin did in 1986. Consequently the provision of Lit 17 339,9 million by Sofin in 1986, first in the form of a credit, later as a grant, constitutes State aid.