lists the aid whic may be considered compatible with the common market. Compatibility with the Treaty must be viewed in the context of the Community as a whole and not in that of a single Member State. In order to ensure the proper functioning of the common market and to take into account the principles laid down in Article 3 (f) of the Treaty, the exceptions to the principle of Article 92 (1) set out in paragraph 3 of that Article must be interpreted strictly when any aid scheme or any individual aid award is examined.
In particular, they may be applied only where the Commission establishes that, without the aid, the free play of market forces would not by itself induce potential recipients to act in such a manner as to contribute to the attainment of one of the objectives sought.
To apply the exceptions to cases which do not contribute to the attainment of such an objective, or where the aid is not essential to that end, would be tantamount to granting undue advantages to the industries or firms of certain Member States, the financial position of which would be bolstered, and might affect trade between Member States and distort competition without this being justified in any way within the meaning of Article 92 (3).
The Italian Government has been unable to give, or the Commission to discover, any justification for a finding that the aid in question falls into any of the categories of exception provided for in Article 92 (3).
With regard to the exceptions provided for in Article 92 (3) (a) and (c) for aid that promotes or facilitates the development of certain areas, the Commission notes that IOR is located at Porto Marghera (Venice). The standard of living there is not abnormally low and there is no serious unemployment there within the meaning of the exception provided for in Article 92 (3) (a), nor is the area in which Porto Marghera is located at present included among those receiving special regional assistance within the meaning of the exception provided for in Article 92 (3) (c). Finally, aid granted in order to cover losses is not designed to contribute to the development of certain economic areas, as set out in the Commission's principles of coordination of regional aid systems (3).
As to the exceptions provided for in Article 92 (3) (b), the aid in favour of IOR is intended neither to promote the execution of an important project of common European interest nor to remedy a serious disturbance in the Italian economy; neither has the Italian Government advanced any arguments in favour of a possible application of these exceptions.
As to the exceptions provided for in Article 92 (3) (c) in favour of aid to facilitate the development of certain economic activities, where such aid does not adversely affect trading conditions to an extent contrary to the common interest, the Commission notes that the aid granted to IOR by the Italian Government via Sofin in 1986 was based on losses sustained by IOR before 15 October 1986.
Without the aid in question IOR would have had to shut down, thereby enabling competitors in Italy, in other Member States and in third countries to expand.
It is the Commission's well-established policy not to consider that loss-compensation facilitates the development of a mature economic activity but, on the contrary, to consider that such aid, more than any other, alters trading conditions in the Community to an extent contrary to the common interest. Consequently, the aid granted in order to compensate IOR's losses does not qualify for the exception set out in Article 92 (3) (c).
The fact that IOR was partly privatized in 1986 and subsequently underwent restructuring due to Finalp's efforts in no way alters this conclusion. Neither can the alleged similarities between this aid and other cases mentioned by the Italian Government lead to a different finding. The Commission must verify the compatibility of every aid on its own merits, taking into account all particularities of the sectors and regions, the type of aid, and the conditions of trade and competition, which may change over time.
Consequently, none of the exemptions provided for in Article 92 can apply to the aid in question.
VIII
In conclusion, the aid of Lit 17 339,9 million is unlawful, the Italian Government having failed to fulfil its obligations pursuant to Article 93 (3) of the EEC Treaty. Furthermore, as set out above, the aid is incompatible because it does not meet the conditions which are required in order to benefit from one of the exemptions provided for in Article 92 (3).
The Commission has decided that in this particular case, repayment of the aid should not be demanded. This decision is based on the time which has passed between the date the aid became known to the Commission and the date this Decision was taken. This long interval would be difficult to justify with respect to the case-law of the Court of justice (4) concerning procedural time limits,
HAS ADOPTED THIS DECISION: