, Decision_act (EU) 1992/329

In forcesince 25 Jul 1990

After an initial investigation of the available information the Commission considered that the Lit 17,3 billion awarded to IOR by its public shareholder did constitute State aid falling under the prohibition laid down in Article 92 (1), to which none of the exemptions set out in the said Article appeared to be applicable.

Neither could the Commission exclude the possibility that the financing of IOR after 15 October 1986 contained additional elements of State aid. On 3 November 1988 the Commission therefore decided to initiate the procedure laid down in Article 93 (2) regarding that aid and invited the Italian Government by letter dated 25 November 1988 to submit its observations.

III

By letter dated 25 January 1989 the Italian Government submitted its observations under the procedure. It stated that Sofin had invested approximately Lit 7 billion in IOR between 1983 and 1986 in order to improve its productivity and efficiency. It stressed that Sofin, by covering IOR's losses, had acted as any investor in a similar position would have done, because Sofin - being the one and only shareholder of IOR until October 1986 - was in any case liable under Italian law for IOR's debts.

The Italian Government also emphasized Finalp's commitment in 1986 to improve IOR's situation, by providing bank guarantees, by investing Lit 14 billion and by means of synergies with other companies it owns.

IOR's financial results in 1987 bore witness to its successful restructuring. Consequently the Italian Government did not subscribe to the Commission's point of view that the payment of Lit 17,3 billion by Sofin constituted State aid. If the Commission should nevertheless interpret this intervention as constituting aid, the Italian Government believed that the exemptions set out in Article 92 (3) should apply to it, given the similarities between this case and three others, which had been cited in the Commission's Seventeenth Report on Competition Policy (points 224, 227 and 229) where the Commission had closed the procedure.

By letter dated 16 February 1989 the Italian Government provided 11 annexes to its letter of 25 January, mainly containing factual information on IOR's accounts and privatization.