Within the framework of the procedure the Italian Government claimed that Sofin had acted as any investor in a similar position would have done by covering IOR's losses, because it was the one and only shareholder of IOR until 15 October 1986 and therefore liable under Italian law for all its debts. The liquidation of IOR would consequently have entailed even higher costs for Sofin.
The Commission cannot subscribe to this point of view. A private investor will normally be reluctant to become the one and only shareholder of a company, if as a consequence he must assume unlimited liability for it; he will make sure that this additional risk is outweighed by additional gains.
In the case of IOR the Commission notes that Finmeccanica (IRI group) became the one and only shareholder of IOR in 1975, when it took over the shares held by Montedison. In 1983 IRI transferred IOR from Finmeccanica to Sofin. According to the information provided by IOR, which was not contradicted by the Italian Government, IOR never had a profitable year between its creation in 1969 and 1988, after its partial privatization. It is the Commission's view that Finmeccanica, Sofin and more generally IRI, by becoming the one and only shareholder of IOR, accepted a risk which a private investor would have refused.
Consequently Sofin's status as unique shareholder of IOR in 1986 in no way alters the qualification made above, that the sum of Lit 17 339,9 million provided by Sofin in 1986, in order to cover part of IOR's losses, constitutes State aid.
Another point made by the Italian Government, by Sofin and by IOR concerned Finalp's financial engagements, which they viewed as a counterpart to the steps taken by Sofin. Finalp would notably finance Lit 14 000 million investments in IOR - in reality it financed Lit 20 000 million - would make IOR profitable again and would release Sofin from its obligations and guarantees as sole shareholder of IOR.
It is the Commission's opinion that Finalp's commitment to restore IOR's profitability was of benefit to itself and to IOR, but much less so to Sofin, which withdrew from IOR completely in March 1989 when it disposed of the remaining 50 % of IOR's shares to Finalp. Finalp's action therefore does not alter the Commission's opinion that the steps taken by Sofin, which related to the period before 15 October 1986, constituted State aid.