The Commission also verified whether additional aid elements were contained in the prices at which the assets of IOR's contact lenses division were sold to Ciba-Geigy and the shares of the remainder of IOR to Finalp in 1986 and 1989.
Ciba-Geigy paid Lit 130 million for the assets of IOR's contact lenses division, which price was well below their book value at the time. Finalp paid the nominal value for the shares of the remainder of IOR - Lit 1 000 per share - in 1986 and 1989.
The Commission notes that in 1986 Sofin invited an accountant other than its regular accountant to establish the current theoretical value of IOR on 31 December 1985. The outcome was a value of minus Lit 32,455 million on that date.
That same year, Sofin invited five possible candidates to take over IOR to submit a bid; when doing so Sofin did not impose any prior conditions which might have influenced the price offered. Of these five candidates, three were interested in buying IOR. Of these three, Finalp's bid was the most attractive, in terms of the price offered as well as the prospects for continuity.
Given that Finalp had no interest in IOR's contact lenses division, Sofin sold the assets of this division - which made monthly losses of Lit 200 million - to Ciba-Geigy, the only candidate it could find, the price being the result of bilateral negotiations.
Having examined the information provided by the Italian Government, Sofin, Finalp and IOR, the Commission accepts that the terms on which IOR was privatized are comparable to those Sofin might have obtained in an open bid and that, consequently, the privatization of IOR did not entail additional elements of State aid.
Finally, the Commission also investigated the transition period between 15 October 1986 and 15 March 1989, in which Sofin still held 50 % of IOR's shares, in order to ensure that, in this period, Sofin had not financed a disproportionately large part of IOR's restructuring programme.
The Italian Government stressed within the framework of the procedure that Sofin had received a fixed dividend on its 50 % stake in IOR, which had been set at Lit 536 million for 1988 and Lit 898 million for 1989. Sofin also received interest - equal to the prime rate awarded by banks - on a loan of Lit 6 billion to IOR.