Even though one may question whether the financial status of IOR justified the use of the prime rate, the Commission is willing to accept that the co-financing of IOR between 15 October 1986 and 15 March 1989 did not entail further elements of State aid.
Consequently, the Commission identifies one aid to IOR, amounting to Lit 17 339,9 million, granted in 1986.
V
By the end of 1985 IOR had a workforce of 494, mainly involved in the production of ophthalmic lenses of glass and of organic matter, traditional as well as contact lenses.
There is trade between Member States in ophthalmic lenses, either unmounted (Nimexe 9001) or mounted (Nimexe 9004) as shown in the following tables:
Exports of lenses (Nimexe 9001 + 9004) from Italy to other Member States
Year to other Member States (ECU million) Percentage of total intra-Community exports (in %) 1985 34,1 13 1986 43,7 14 1987 48,7 15 1988 50,1 15
Imports of lenses (Nimexe 9001 + 9004) into Italy from other Member States
Year from other Member States (ECU million) Percentage of total intra-Community imports (in %) 1985 29,6 12 1986 32,7 12 1987 34,2 12 1988 41,2 12
There is competition between manufacturers of ophthalmic lenses. According to the date provided within the framework of the procedure, IOR accounted for 27 % of Italian production of lenses in 1985, 27,7 % in 1986 and - further to the split-off of its contact lenses division - 22,2 % in 1987.
No precise data on IOR's market share in the Community are available. An approximation was provided by Sofin, according to which IOR's sales of contact lenses in 1984 amounted to 3,8 % of total consumption in 1983 in Italy, Germany, France and the United Kingdom. By extrapolating these data on the basis of population, IOR's market share for contact lenses in the Community of Ten in 1983/84 was approximately 3,2 %. For traditional ophthalmic lenses made of glass, IOR's sales represented 4,5 % of consumption in the four large Member States, which can be extrapolated to an approximate market share of 3,8 % in the Community of Ten in 1983/84. Similarly, its market share for plastic lenses was 7,7 % in the four large Member States and approximately 6,5 % in the Community.
The traditional position of expensive brand lenses has gradually been eroded by cheaper, less known alternatives, a growing part of which is imported from third countries.
The Community as a whole is a net exporter of ophthalmic lenses, albeit with a decreasing margin, as shown in the following table.