The four largest producers - Montepolimeri, Hoechst, ICI and Shell - formed the nucleus of the arrangements and constituted an unofficial directorate the members of which considered themselves to have a special responsibility towards ensuring the success of the cartel.
Montepolimeri and ICI each held at some stage the chairmanship of the group and from the documentation it is apparent that this role was not a nominal one only. ICI in particular insisted that it would assume the responsibility for leading the group only on condition that greater efforts were made by all to achieve price rises and took the initiative in proposing a new and more effective quota system.
The Commission does not consider that any substantial individual mitigating factor arises from the fact that Shell did not attend the plenary sessions. It was involved from the beginning in the price initiatives and quota systems. Operating companies of the group took part in local meetings. Even before it began to attend 'pre-meetings' of the 'big four' in October 1982 it was meeting other major producers in detailed discussions on the matters covered by the regular bosses' and experts' sessions.
Similarly the fact that Hercules did not communicate its own detailed sales figures to the other producers, while itself benefiting from the information they supplied, does not constitute a mitigating factor.
Nor does the Commission accept that any substantial distinction can be made between the other producers on the basis of their individual degree of commitment to the agreed arrangements. Perception of individual interest may sometimes have diverged but all the producers were frequent attenders at the meetings and took steps to implement the cartel's decisions.
In the case of Petrofina, Rhône-Poulenc and ANIC, the Commission takes into account the shorter duration of their participation in the arrangements as compared with the other producers.
The Commission also takes into account that a very few of the producers cooperated (but not to the extent
that they claim) with the Commission's investigations, at least once the incriminating evidence had been discovered.
HAS ADOPTED THIS DECISION: