, Decision_act (EU) 1986/398

In force

In the present case the producers, by subscribing to a common plan to regulate prices and supply in the polypropylene market, participated in an overall framework agreement which was manifested in a series of more detailed sub-agreements worked out from time to time.

82.

In the detailed working out of the overall plan express agreement was reached in many areas (individual price initiatives and annual quota schemes). In some cases the producers may not have reached a consensus on a definitive scheme, such as quotas for 1981 and 1982. However their adoption of stopgap measures including exchange of information and the monitoring of actual monthly sales against achievements in some previous reference period not only involves an express agreement to set up and operate such measures but also indicates an implied agreement to maintain as far as possible the respective positions of the producers.

Given the detailed evidence on the price initiatives described in points 28 to 51, the Commission considers that even before 1979 the various initiatives reported as being 'led' by one or other producer and 'followed' by the others also resulted from an agreement between them.

This is the case for example with the December 1977 initiative (points 16 and 17). Even in front of customers at the EATP meetings producers like Hercules, Hoechst, ICI, LINZ, Rhône-Poulenc, SAGA and Solvay were stressing the perceived need for concerted action to increase prices. There was further contact on pricing between the producers outside the EATP meetings. In the light of these admitted contacts the Commission considers that behind the device of one or more producers complaining of inadequate levels of profitability and suggesting joint action while the others expressed 'support' for such moves lay on existing agreement on pricing. (Even in the absence of further contacts such a device might still indicate a sufficient consensus for an agreement within the meaning of Article 85 (1).)

83.

The conclusion that there is one continuing agreement is not altered by the fact that some producers inevitably were not present at every meeting. Any 'initiative' took several months to plan and to implement and it would make little difference to the involvement of a producer if absent on occasion. In any case, the normal practice was for absentees to be informed of what had been decided in meetings. All

the undertakings to which this Decision is addressed