On 1 January 1984 SAGA Petrokjemi, which had been constituted as a partnership with legal personality under Norwegian law, ceased to exist as a separate legal entity, being absorbed into Statoil. It now forms a separate profit centre in the Statoil organization. By virtue of the merger of SAGA Petrokjemi with Statoil, Statoil took over the one-third share in IS Norpolefin and the benefit of the management agreement held until then by SAGA Petrokjemi. Statoil now operates in its own name the thermoplastics business formerly represented by SAGA Petrokjemi, continuing as 'manager' of the Norpolefin operation. The marketing subsidiaries of SAGA Petrokjemi in Denmark and the United Kingdom are now styled as subsidiaries of Statoil but perform exactly the same function as before in relation to the sale and marketing of thermoplastics.
Statoil contends that it is not liable for any infringements which may have been committed by
SAGA Petrokjemi, since that undertaking ceased to exist on 1 January 1984, that is between the date the alleged behaviour took place and the time the Commission issued statements of objections.
It is accepted by the Commission that there is no evidence that Statoil continued the infringement by participating in meetings or otherwise after the takeover of SAGA Petrokjemi. Nor is it suggested that the acquisition by Statoil was intended to frustrate the application of EEC competition rules. Moreover, even though Statoil has always been a partner in the Norpolefin operation (originally having a one third interest and now two-thirds) it is accepted that any infringement of Article 85 was committed not by Norpolefin but by SAGA Petrokjemi by reason of its management and marketing function.
It cannot seriously be contested that had SAGA Petrokjemi continued in existence in its original form the Commission could have imposed a fine upon it for its participation in the cartel in so far as this involved its function inside the EEC.
The essential issue for the purposes of the present case is whether following the merger and despite the changes in structure and legal form the undertaking which committed the infringement is still in existence or whether it has been liquidated.
The question is one to be determined exclusively by reference to the rules of Community law and cannot be made to depend upon rules of national law.