, Decision_act (EU) 1986/398

In force

The deliveries of most producers in the years when a system was in operation did not generally show a sharp variance from the quota or target which had been allocated (see Table 8 in Annex). For the years 1981 and 1982 when no quota system could be agreed it was inevitable that the more ambitious producers would increase their share of the market as compared with the previous year or period of reference. However, by the exchange each month of information on deliveries the other producers could at least adjust their own conduct and perception of the market so as to take account of the attitude of the more aggressive producers. Even during 1981 and 1982, however, a broad equilibrium between producers as compared with the previous years was maintained.

Some producers pointed to variances between their original target tonnage and their actual deliveries in the year in question (particularly in 1980) and argued that this phenomenon disproved the existence of any quota system. In fact during this year the 'tonnage' targets had been continuously revised and the agreed market division retained overall in terms of percentage share. ATO, for example, stressed the progressive

increase in the tonnage which it had sold each year in western Europe (from 39 000 tonnes in 1979 to 45 000 tonnes in 1982). In fact its achieved market share in percentage terms was constant throughout (between 3,1 % and 3,2 %) and corresponded almost precisely with its percentage target for each year.

It was also argued that the changes in the market share of some producers since 1977 were evidence of 'unrestricted' competition. This argument overlooks the fact that quotas or targets were agreed so as to take account of the ambitions of the newcomers and the larger firms were willing to accept some reduction in their own market share in the interests of increasing price levels.

92.

The fact that in practice the cartelization of the market was incomplete and did not entirely exclude the operation of competitive forces does not preclude application of Article 85. Given the large number of producers, their divergent commercial interests and the absence of any enforceable measures of constraint in the event of non-compliance by a producer with agreed arrangements, no cartel could control totally the activities of the participants.