producers ordering or advising their national sales offices to raise their prices to the new levels or otherwise carry out actions earlier agreed in a meeting. They also set up system of regular reporting of their activities which allowed for the monitoring of agreed plans.
The producers' consensus involved on the part of all of them an acceptance if not a positive intention that an identified plan was envisaged and would be carried out. Whatever the unrecorded mental reservations of some may have been on a particular scheme or price initiative they were deeply involved in the overall plan to fix prices and divide up the market. The fact that on some occasions producers may not have maintained their initial resolve and gave concessions to customers on price which undermined the 'initiative' does not preclude an unlawful agreement having been reached within the meaning of Article 85 (1). Indeed, the instances of allegedly 'unruly' or 'disruptive' pricing by an individual producer from time to time attempting to gain market position at the expense of the others (before whom the 'transgressor' could be called upon to explain himself) does not negate the overwhelming evidence of a concerted plan to regulate the market.
In the particular case of Hercules the undertaking cannot escape responsibility for the infringement by arguing that the attendance of its representative was 'unofficial' or that he withheld certain information from the other producers.
Concerted Practices
The Commission considers that the operation of the cartel, being based on a common and detailed plan, constituted an 'agreement' within the meaning of Article 85 (1).
The concepts of 'agreements' and 'concerted practices' are distinct, but cases may arise where collusion presents some of the elements of both forms of prohibited cooperation.
A concerted practice relates to a form of cooperation between undertakings which without having reached the stage where an agreement properly so-called has been concluded, knowingly substitutes practical cooperation for the risks of competition.