The Commission does not accept the argument implicit in the written and oral observations of several of the producers and in the econometric study which they commissioned that in the absence of their arrangements market developments would have been the same. What might have occurred had there been no agreement is a matter of speculation but it is significant that the producers themselves acknowledged the effectiveness of their meetings in rejecting the suggestion in May 1982 that they cease to meet, since it was considered better, if supply and demand were in equilibrium, to take 'active steps' to move prices up rather than leave it to the market.
Effect upon trade between Member States
The agreement between the producers was apt to have an appreciable effect upon trade between Member States.
Article 85 is aimed at agreements which might harm the attainment of a single market between the Member States, whether by partitioning national markets or by affecting the structure of competition within the common market.
In the present case the pervasive nature of the collusive agreement, which covered virtually all trade throughout the EEC (and other western European countries) in a major industrial product, must automatically result in the diversion of trade from the channels which would have developed in the absence of such an agreement.
Fixing prices at an artificial level by agreement rather than by leaving the market to find its own balance impaired the structure of competition throughout the Community. The undertakings were relieved of the immediate need to respond to market forces and deal with the claimed excess capacity problem.
The fixing of target prices for each Member State, although needing to take some account of the prevailing local conditions - discussed in detail in national meetings - must have distorted the pattern of trade and the effect on price levels of differences in efficiency between producers. The system of account leadership, in directing customers to particular named producers, aggravated the effect of the pricing arrangements.