Petrofina did not have a separate marketing function outside Montefina - the joint Montepolimeri-Fina production company - until March 1982. Until that date Montefina sold the production of the Feluy plant on behalf of both the parents. However, for the purposes of calculating quotas, the entitlement of each of the parent companies was usually treated separately during this period. Petrofina was thus a participant in its own right in quota arrangements from 1980 onwards. Even if this were not the case, Petrofina must still take joint responsibility for any participation in the cartel by Montefina until March 1982.
Regulation (EEC) N° 2988/74
Several producers named in connection with the 'floor price agreement' in mid-1977 have argued that such arrangements were entirely separate from any later system of regular meetings which developed so that the Commission is precluded from imposing any fines by virtue of Regulation (EEC) N° 2988/74 (9) which applies a five year limitation period.
The Commission does not accept that the 'floor price' arrangements in mid-1977 were so distinct from the producers' later conduct dating from the end of 1977 as to benefit from the Regulation. The difference between the 'floor prices' and the 'minimum' or 'target' prices which were later fixed in regular meetings is largely one of terminology. Both ICI and Shell were at pains to emphasize that the 'floor price' discussions were not limited to the four major producers but involved others. The same situation - the arrival of new producers and the perceived slide in price levels - was said to be behind the 'floor price' system and the later more structured meetings.
Given the clear factual and circumstantial lien between the arrangements the Commission considers that in considering fines it is not precluded by Regulation (EEC) N° 2988/74 from taking account of the so-called 'floor price' agreement of mid-1977.
Duration of the infringement
The involvement of the four majors - Hoechst, ICI, Montepolimeri and Shell - dates from the 'floor price agreement' made in mid-1977 and the 'initiative' led by Montepolimeri (then Montedison) at the end of the year.
Hercules, LINZ, Rhône-Poulenc, SAGA and Solvay all expressed their 'support' for the price initiative of December 1977 in circumstances which indicated their adherence to and association with a common design going far beyond independent business judgment.