The export prohibitions imposed on the United Kingdom dealers are the principal infringements taken into account. In this respect the Commission bears in mind that the price differences for Gravindex pregnancy tests in 1973 to 1978 were considerable, as is shown by Chart I. The prohibition on exports by British dealers to other EEC Member States prevented the Gravindex products from the United Kingdom, where the prices were the lowest in the EEC, having an influence on the higher price levels (up to 3 775 times higher) in other Member States.
In determining the gravity of the infringement it must be taken into account that Ortho UK and Cilag Alsbach sought to prevent exports by chemists in a determined and vigorous manner and continued to do this even after the formal export prohibitions were removed from Ortho's terms of trading. The means employed included measures to identify the exporters, threatening to cut off a dealer's supplies and even a refusal to supply certain chemists by withholding supplies totally or by drastically limiting them.
Moreover, Cilag Alsbach continued its actions even after the Decision of the Court of Justice of 20 May 1976 in the Centrafarm case although it was aware - as it has admitted - that after that Decision it was unlawful to hinder parallel imports.
The fact that Ortho UK imposed the export prohibition and that Cilag Alsbach insisted on its application, shows that the object of their combined actions was to maintain the separation of, in particular, the United Kingdom and German markets and the wide difference between the prices in the UK and elsewhere. They intended to protect their marketing policies from any possible change in the market and price situation.
On the other hand it is taken into account that the export prohibitions imposed on the German dealers had little practical significance since prices in other markets were and continued to be lower and exports therefore of no interest. Nevertheless they expressed the general policy of preventing parallel exports in any circumstances and this must be regarded as a grave contravention even if for economic reasons it was not effective.
Ortho UK, Cilag Alsbach and Cilag Schaffhausen are subsidiaries of Johnson & Johnson and the various measures to prevent parallel exports were taken in their common interest, under the control and with the knowledge of the parent company.