The prohibition of exports from the United Kingdom continued to be applied after the amendment of the terms of trading in January 1977. Ortho changed the wording so that ostensibly only exports to non-EEC countries were still prohibited, but in reality, exports to EEC countries were still not allowed. On the contrary, Ortho UK stressed to those dealers which it supposed were exporting, that exports to EEC countries were still prohibited. It made and carried out threats to withhold or delay supplies, and also instituted a system of checks on dealers. The dealers knew that the present and future deliveries were obtainable only if they complied with the request not to export. Those actions were pursued both before and after the amendment of the terms of trading in January 1977 without any interruption. After that date they were even intensified in order to bring to an end the exports of Gravindex pregnancy tests. The continued efforts to prevent dealers from exporting compelled those dealers to accept the fact that exporting was still not allowed.
The contracts of sale of Ortho UK were still, therefore, subject to prohibitions of exports, which prohibitions formed an integral part of agreements within the meaning of Article 85 (1). For the purpose of determining the applicability of Article 85 (1), the facts that it was not in the dealers' interests to observe the prohibition and that some of them did not do so, are irrelevant ; that Article extends to any distribution system whose object is to restrict competition, whether or not it is successful in doing so.
B. Restriction of competition
In the UK trade price lists, applied by Ortho UK until January 1977, a provision was embodied prohibiting export from the United Kingdom except by prior arrangement. The "Preislisten" applied by Cilag Alsbach until 28 February 1978 contained a provision prohibiting direct or indirect resale to other countries. These provisions had as their object the restriction of competition within the common market. They were aimed at preventing buyers in the United Kingdom and Germany from reselling the products of Ortho UK and Cilag Alsbach to other countries including the common market countries and thus from competing in those countries. Article 85 (1) is applicable even if the export prohibitions were not always enforced as the exporting dealers' supplies were constantly at risk in the event of the exports becoming known to the supplier.