, Decision_act (EU) 1980/1283

In forcesince 25 Nov 1980
35.

An export prohibition is, by its very nature, liable to affect trade between Member States. Such a condition has as its object to impede trade between Member States or to confine such trade to channels chosen by the undertaking imposing the prohibition. In this case the restrictions prevented trade between, in particular, the United Kingdom and other Member States, caused or at least contributed to an artificial partitioning of the common market and were likely to hinder the establishment of a single market among Member States.

36.

This effect on trade between Member States has been appreciable. The only trade in Gravindex pregnancy tests between the United Kingdom and the other Member States, and in particular Germany, was that done by so-called "parallel importers". Every influence on this trade has an appreciable effect, especially when price differences exist to an appreciable extent (e.g. the price in Germany is 3 775 times the price in the UK) providing considerable incentive and scope for exports from the United Kingdom to Germany. It therefore seems reasonable to conclude that but for the export prohibition there could have been a significant flow of Gravindex tests from the UK to Germany with a (1)See judgment of 31 October 1974, Case No 16/74 (Centrafarm v. Sterling Drug) [1974] ECR 1183. corresponding effect on the German price and corresponding benefits to German users. Moreover, the existence of price differences was the reason for the actions of Ortho UK, as is shown for instance by the letter from Ortho UK to the chemist of 7 April 1976. But even if such important price differences did not exist at a given moment, e.g. between Germany and the other Member States for the product Gravindex, this situation might have changed. Therefore also the export ban imposed by Cilag Alsbach is likely to affect trade between Member States to an appreciable degree, especially taking into account Cilag Alsbach's position on the market (1).

III.

INAPPLICABILITY OF ARTICLE 85 (3)