In fact Ortho UK and Cilag Alsbach are not only subject both in theory and in practice to the general power of Johnson & Johnson to give policy directives, being wholly-owned subsidiaries, but are also dependent on the parent company for the goods involved, namely Gravindex slide tests. The companies Ortho UK and Cilag Alsbach only bottle and package this product. There is no question of an autonomous commercial policy for the European subsidiaries. It is established that Cilag Schaffhausen brought the parent company into this affair, not only to inform it, but with the express purpose of finding a solution to - quoting them - "a very unpleasant and important problem", using the parent company's authoritative power. If the various companies in the group had really been accustomed to operating independently of each other, Ortho UK would be unlikely to have imposed an export prohibition at all, and it would certainly not have devoted a considerable amount of management effort to enforcing it, when the only result of such actions, from Ortho UK's point of view, would be a reduction in its own sales potential. None of the enforcement measures taken by the various companies and described at points 15 to 22 above is explicable otherwise than in the context of a general group policy of maintaining separate national markets with different prices. After the date of Cilag Schaffhausen's letter of 22 March 1976 to Dr Fuller (see point 18), the group continued to operate the policy of partitioning the common market. This shows that the parent company knew of this policy, and approved of it.
Therefore, the Commission regards Ortho UK, Cilag Schaffhausen, Cilag Alsbach and Johnson & Johnson as jointly responsible and must impose a fine on them jointly and severally. However, this finding does not affect the amount of the fine.
The companies involved sell many products, and the maximum fine which could be imposed under Regulation No 17 would be 10 % of total turnover in all products. This decision concerns an infringement in connection with one product. The imposition of export bans on trade between Member States must always be regarded as a particularly grave infringement, justifying the imposition of fines reflecting this fact.