, Decision_act (EU) 1980/1283

In forcesince 25 Nov 1980

Orders from three chemists, placed during May and June 1977, were held up for six to seven months, although Ortho UK's stocks were sufficient at the times these orders were placed, and other customers' orders were dealt with much more quickly. Ortho UK claims that the delay in deliveries was caused by an unprecedented increase of orders in the second half of 1977 so that from May 1977, Ortho UK had an excess of orders on hand over its stocks. However, the excess of unserved orders was mainly due to a shortage of 200 test packs and yet the orders of the three chemists called for 20/25 test packs. Although Ortho UK argues that 20/25 test packs may be used to satisfy orders for the 200 test pack, when the latter is in short supply, there is no evidence of this substitution having been carried out in practice.

In August 1977 the 20 test pack was withdrawn from the UK market. In March 1978 the price of the 25 test pack was raised 20 % and in August 1978 by a further 9 75 %. Also in August 1978, the price of the 200 test pack was raised 10 %. Thus three of the four possibilities for action against exports of Gravindex slide tests as indicated in the letter from Ortho UK of 18 May 1977 were put into effect.

The Commission has no information on any enforcement of a prohibition on exports by Ortho UK after January 1978.

23.

Cilag Alsbach for its part ceased its efforts to stop imports of Gravindex products in July 1977, recognizing expressly that, since the decision of the Court of Justice of May 1976 in the Centrafarm case, they were aware that it is unlawful to prohibit or hinder "parallel imports" (see Cilag Alsbach internal note of 21 July 1977).

F. Proceeding

24.

This proceeding is brought only against Johnson & Johnson, Ortho UK, Cilag Schaffhausen and Cilag Alsbach and not against their customers, the United Kingdom and German chemists who were formally parties to the agreements involved, because the purpose (1)Judgment of the Court of Justice 13 July 1966, Case Nos 56-58/64 (Grundig/Consten) (1966) European Court Reports 322. Decisions of the Commission of 1 December and 21 December 1976 (Miller International and Theal/Watts) (OJ No L 357, 29.12.1976, p. 40 and OJ No L 39, 10.2.1977, p. 19). of the export ban was to protect the partitioning of the national markets. The restrictive agreements with the chemists were only the vehicle for this protective policy, which was indeed contrary to the interests of those chemists.