, Decision_act (EU) 1980/257

In forcesince 8 Feb 1980
37.

The prohibition in Article 65 (1) applies not only to the concerted activities in which BDS's members engaged when determining their selling prices, but also to the association's own activities which enabled the pricing agreement to be organized in the first place. BDS's role is crucial to the success of the information system. It is responsible for all the arrangements needed to circulate the revised ex-stock price lists of leading steel stockholders to the other members of the association as quickly as possible. These arrangements include : informing members of the existence of a new price list, obtaining consent for its circulation, reproducing the price lists and distributing the copies to the relevant dealers. Thus all the most important steps towards a uniform pricing policy for German steel stockholders were taken by BDS. To this extent BDS's activities in the field of price information go far beyond the bounds of the activities that association may engage in according to the third sentence of the first paragraph of Article 48 of the Treaty, for they amount to practices which have the object of restricting or distorting competition in the common market. When followed, if only de facto, by an association of undertakings, such practices are prohibited by anti-trust law (paragraph 15).

38.

BDS fails in its submission that the printing and distribution of new ex-stock price lists are undertaken by its distribution company and are by their very nature commercial activities. The BDS distribution company is a separately accountable undertaking working on behalf of the association and controlled by it. BDS must therefore be considered fully responsible for any anticompetitive practices pursued by its marketing company. The fact that BDS's distribution company sold its copies of major dealers' price lists to (1)Judgment of the Court of 16 December 1975 : Joined Cases 40 to 48, 50, 54 to 56, 111, 113 and 114/73 (Suiker Unie et al. v. Commission) : [1975] ECR 1663, 1942. (2)Judgment of the Court of Justice, 17 October 1972 : Case 8/72 (Vereniging van Cementhandelaren v. Commission) : [1972] ECR 977, 990.