, Decision_act (EU) 1980/257

In forcesince 8 Feb 1980
20.

BDS's involvement in price formation since 1973 is likewise incompatible with Article 65 (1) of the Treaty, since it has been directed towards standardizing the prices charged by its members for ex-stock sales, and thus towards setting the balance of prices at a level differing from that which would have been obtained in normal competition conditions. (1)Judgment of the Court of Justice, 19 March 1964 : Case 67/63 (SOREMA v. High Authority) [1964] ECR 151, 162.

(i)

Information on producer price changes

21.

No objection can, however, be taken to the fact that BDS informed its members of changes in producer prices (see I B (i)). Under Article 60 (2) of the Treaty, steel producers are obliged to publish their price scales and conditions of sale in the common market. Thus details of ex-works prices are available to everyone, including stockholders, be they supplied direct by the producer or by direct-dealing stockholders. In re-printing and distributing ex-works price lists BDS aims to make it easier for those of its members who do not deal direct to obtain information, and to even out any advantage the directly-supplied dealers may gain from obtaining their information at source. This policy is also in line with the objectives embodied in Article 60 (2) in that it encourages market transparency at production level. To this extent it is, for the purposes of the third sentence of the first paragraph of Article 48, a legitimate activity for an association to pursue. There is no risk of a distortion of the normal conditions of competition to the detriment of the direct-dealing stockholder as long as the expense involved in reprinting and distributing price lists is met in its entirety by those BDS member companies that benefit from it.

(ii)

The role of BDS in the compilation of model calculations

22.

On the other hand, BDS's involvement in producing model calculations for its members constitutes, at least in the form it has taken to date (see I.B (ii)), an infringement of Article 65 (1) of the Treaty.