, Decision_act (EU) 1980/257

In forcesince 8 Feb 1980
23.

The Commission considers that model calculations shared by a number of firms are unobjectionable for the purposes of anti-trust law only where they go no further than indicating, analysing, explaining and classifying the separate cost components recognized as essential to price formation, and working out methods for imputing expenditure to the various cost headings (products or services). Model calculations containing specific values are, on the contrary, to be viewed as recommendations capable of restricting competition (1).

24.

This applies to the model used since 1973 for determining "free ex-stock prices". The form and the construction of this model are admittedly unobjectionable : the classification of individual rolled steel products according to product types and groups, the attention paid to size and quality, the variations in stocking costs according to turnover frequency for the products in question and the distribution of fixed costs according to contract weights appear to be appropriate and a useful way of helping the user of the calculating system to make a realistic calculation of his costs. The model calculations supplied by BDS do, however, overstep the permissible limits in that they set actual values on the individual components. The same applies to the graduated extras for small quantities calculated according to average reference figures and to the "works dimensional extra", which varies according to turnover rate. Both types of extra vary according to product and type of product (long and flat products) and are graded into four groups ("very popular", "popular", "less popular", "unpopular") ; they are imposed in terms of DM per tonne. The "contract/overhead costs" are also imputed to the various cost headings at a fixed rate in DM per tonne. Lastly, the lists include a profit margin of 5 % for all stockholders.

25.

Model calculations of this type have the effect of recommendations. They encourage the user companies to work from the figures contained in the model, or at least to keep close to them, when calculating their costs and thus indirectly when setting their selling prices. To this extent it is immaterial whether the cost components are expressed in straight figures or in the form of percentage surcharges. Either way, what may once have been offered as a service to explain to companies the various ways of achieving cost-related price formation has become a means of exerting a real, powerful influence on their pricing policy.