In its written and oral comments BDS has agreed that the Commission's findings, as set out above, are substantially accurate. It does, however, take issue with the conclusion that it has infringed the ECSC competition rules. Its argument can be summarized as follows : its system of price formation takes account of actual circumstances on the steel market. It helps chiefly to stabilize the market in times of recession - an aim actively pursued by the Community institutions themselves. Its compatibility with the Treaty is further supported by the fact that it furthers market transparency. It offers steel distributing undertakings a chance of publicizing their prices similar to that available to steel producers under Article 60 (2).
APPLICABILITY OF ARTICLE 65 (1)
Article 65 (1) of the ECSC Treaty reads : "All agreements between undertakings, decisions by associations of undertakings and concerted practices tending directly or indirectly to prevent, restrict or distort normal competition within the common market shall be prohibited ...".
The effect of this provision is not restricted to such formal decisions as are taken in accordance with the procedure laid down in the association's constitution, in conformity with its objects as defined in that constitution, and are legally binding on all its members. If a decision by an association aims at or even only tends towards determining or influencing its members' competitive behaviour it is caught by Article 65 (1), regardless of whether the decision is binding or simply a recommendation. The actual conduct of an association of undertakings, its bodies or its subsidiary organs is the same thing as a "decision" for the purposes of Article 65 (1), since it must be assumed that the association does not act without the express or tacit approval of its members. If such actions tend in themselves to restrict or distort competition they are automatically caught by the prohibition.