By taking part in the information system, BDS's member firms are induced to determine their prices in concert, instead of at their own discretion. Dealers who receive the new price lists decided on by the price leaders regularly follow their example. The price leaders themselves actively encourage this process of alignment by consenting to the circulation of their price lists ; furthermore, as soon as they decide on price changes they can predict and allow for their competitors' reactions, particularly since they themselves largely determine these reactions, simply by giving advance notice of their market strategy.
This type of system is in conflict with the basic principle underlying the rules on competition in the Treaty, which is that each commercial operator must determine independently the policy he intends to adopt on the common market. This requirement of independence does not deprive undertakings of the right to adapt themselves intelligently to the existing and anticipated conduct of their competitors. It does, however, strictly preclude any direct or indirect contact between undertakings, the object or effect whereof is either to influence the conduct on the market of an actual or potential competitor or to disclose to such a competitor the course of conduct which they themselves have decided to adopt or contemplate adopting on the market (1).
The coordination of selling prices results in a considerable distortion of the competitive relations between steel stockholders on the German market. BDS supplies all its members with the major dealers' revised ex-stock price lists. These price lists are in considerable demand, which is a sufficient reason to justify their being reprinted by BDS's distribution company from purely commercial considerations. It follows that many, if not most, of BDS's members have advance warning of the pricing policy the major dealers are about to follow, and adjust their own price lists accordingly. Thus, as an inevitable result of the information system described above, the member firms determine their prices to a large extent by reference to uniform criteria which bear no relation to the differing cost structures experienced by each, nor to the prevailing regional or local market conditions, which in turn has the effect of setting prices for ex-stock deliveries at an artificial level. This applies to all ex-stock sales of steel products.