, Decision_act (EU) 1980/257

In forcesince 8 Feb 1980
28.

The use of the existing model calculation restricts price competition between German steel stockholders. It is freely admitted that the models are available to all BDS members, and actually used many of the undertakings for which they are designed. These undertakings are encouraged to base their own calculations on the exact figures used in the model with the result that, rather than assessing their operating costs independently on the basis of their own experience, they follow a common, standardized set of values. This parallelism of cost calculating methods results in the harmonization of the pricing policy followed by the undertakings concerned. The model calculations provided by BDS offer exact figures for most price components including a profit margin. The remaining components which are not specified in the model ("effective basic price" or "effective component price, freight costs, constant cost headings") are by nature predetermined and largely beyond the stockholders control. Furthermore, the cost price to the dealer, which is by far the most important cost component, varies only slightly owing to the uniform pricing policy followed by the producers. Given the circumstances, competition in the stockholding trade is restricted almost entirely to the choice of discounts the dealer may offer his customers.

29.

BDS bears a substantial amount of the responsibility for the restriction of pricing competition between German steel stockholders. BDS approved the model calculations in question and distributed them for use by its member firms. It should therefore be considered as the originating force behind its members' concerted pricing policy. It is not necessary to establish whether the model calculations were produced by the individual dealers themselves or with the active cooperation of BDS experts, or whether they were prepared by the association's specialized committees ; either way the question is of no practical significance. Nor is it necessary to determine whether the model calculations were the result of a formal decision, and whether they were expressly described as "recommendations". As explained above (paragraph 15), the prohibition in Article 65 (1) of the Treaty extends to actions taken by an association of undertakings, its organs, its committees or its working groups where such activities are liable to prevent, restrict or distort normal competition in the common market.