, Decision_act (EU) 1980/257

In forcesince 8 Feb 1980

This interpretation is fully in accordance with the letter, the spirit and the purpose of Article 65, which is generally to prohibit all agreements, decisions and practices tending to prevent, restrict or distort normal competition. By the same token it applies to associations to the extent that their own activity or that of their member undertakings tends to produce the effects which the Article seeks to prevent. This is confirmed by a reading of Article 48, which allows associations to engage in any activity not contrary to the provisions of the Treaty (1).

16.

As an association of undertakings, BDS is subject to the provisions of Article 65 since its members are undertakings covered by Article 80.

A. Restrictions resulting from the ex-stock price lists (NSP lists) at the time of the investigation

17.

Between 1970 and 1972 BDS continually acted in infringement of Article 65 (1) by arranging the compilation and distribution amongst its members of "net ex-stock price lists" for sales of rolled steel products (see I. A).

It is clear from their contents alone that these NSP lists were apt to restrict competition since the dealers' price they contained were all based on a uniform system of calculations. Not only were these prices based on standardized producer prices, but the other price components, such as freight charges up to and beyond first destination, dealers' overheads, extra charges for small quantities and profits, were included in detail. The only differences were between groups of products and distribution zones, and the NSP lists themselves defined the relevant products and zones in their own terms, as well as the special rates applicable to each. In addition, the lists indicated a uniform discount margin. The distribution of this type of net price list to members of the association inevitably encouraged them to adopt a uniform pricing method and, by extension, a uniform pricing policy, which entirely ignored the situation of each individual steel stockholder, especially his own particular structure and competitive position.