The interested parties further submit that the mandatory rebate of 16 % of the turnover forces mainly small and medium sized firms into bankruptcy, which were healthy firms before the introduction of the rebate, but whose profit margins are not big enough to be able to bear its additional costs. In this regard the third parties in particular point to the fact that the combination of the mandatory price freeze with the Preismoratorium prevents firms from compensating the additional costs of the former through an increase in prices. It is, therefore, argued that the possibility of granting exemptions does not lead to a selective advantage, but rather prevents discrimination of smaller undertakings with small profit margins. In this sense, the measure must be seen as a hardship clause, reducing the impact of the price freezes to a proportionate level. It is argued that the price freezes would be in breach of the freedom to conduct a business, as laid down in Article 16 of the Charter, without such a hardship clause. In this regard all beneficiaries point to the fact that they would not be firms in financial difficulties if it were not for the price freezes. In light of this direct causal link between the legislation introducing the price freezes and their financial difficulties, the beneficiaries underline the importance of a hardship clause.
43 4. COMMENTS FROM INTERESTED PARTIES, Decision_act (EU) 2015/1300
In forcesince 27 Mar 2015