38 4. COMMENTS FROM INTERESTED PARTIES, Decision_act (EU) 2015/1300

In forcesince 27 Mar 2015

The BPI stressed that the opening decision did not take into account that applicants for exemptions from the price freeze must prove a causal link between their financial difficulties and said price freeze, meaning that the successful applicants would not have been in financial difficulties if it were not for the price freeze. It, furthermore, argued that no State resources are involved as both private and public health insurances should be regarded as being independent from the State. It submitted, in analogy to similar case law by the Court concerning general tax measures, that the measure is not selective but constitutes a general measure as the German constitution requires the legislature to foresee hardship clauses to prevent excessive interferences into the rights of private parties. Furthermore, the BPI argued that the measure is not imputable to Germany, as the German implementation of Article 4(2) of Directive 89/105 is directly required by EU primary law, namely Articles 15, 16 and 52 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights [Charter of Fundamental Rights of the European Union (OJ C 326, 26.10.2012, p. 391). Hereinafter ‘the Charter’.]. In case the Commission, nevertheless, concludes that the measure constitutes State aid, the BPI submits that the R&R Guidelines pursue different aims (restructuring of firms in difficulties) than the measure (hardship clause preventing German legislation from forcing otherwise healthy undertakings into bankruptcy) and should, therefore, not be applicable. Thus, the compatibility should rather be assessed directly on the basis of the Treaty. In particular, the BPI points out that Article 168(7) TFEU states that the EU must respect the responsibilities of the Member States for the definition of their health policy and for the organisation and delivery of health services and medical care, including the allocation of the resources assigned to health services and medical care.