As explained in recitals 15 and 16, the privatisation of the operation of Ahoy Rotterdam NV and the lease of the complex were based on the assumption that the planned investment [In particular the expansion of the capacity of the Arena by the addition of extra seats.] was necessary to maintain the value of the complex but would not produce any additional revenues for the operator [This assumption was used in the Deloitte report determining a market rent for the Ahoy complex.]. In this respect, the Commission would point out that the independent consultant has confirmed that the assumption made in the Deloitte report that an increase in the capacity of the Ahoy Arena as a result of the intended investment would not automatically produce additional value for the operator was a defensible one, in view of the dynamics of the events market, possible new competitors, and the related uncertainties and risks. The Commission agrees with the findings of the independent consultant, and concludes that this assumption was justified, taking into account among other things Ahoy’s unique market position, the presence and behaviour of other operators in the market [According to the independent consultant, Amsterdam RAI, for example, was investing up to EUR 105 million in upgrading its complex in the period 2003–2008.], and the fact that the operation of the complex could be hampered by the renovation work for a fairly long time.
55 VII. ASSESSMENT IN THE LIGHT OF THE STATE AID RULES State aid within the meaning of Article 87(1) of the EC Treaty › 2. Advantage › Economic advantage to the operator, Decision_act (EU) 2009/713
In forcesince 21 Oct 2008