38 VI. THE INDEPENDENT CONSULTANT’S STUDY, Decision_act (EU) 2009/713

In forcesince 21 Oct 2008

As part of the investigation, the Commission selected an independent consultant, ECORYS Nederland BV, to carry out a review of the valuation reports prepared by Deloitte [One report, entitled ‘Project Nadal’, valued the shares in Ahoy Rotterdam NV at EUR 1,7 million; the other, ‘Waardering Ahoy’, put the market level of rent for the Ahoy complex at EUR 2,6 million.], which had served as a basis for the municipality when it sold the operation of Ahoy Rotterdam NV and leased the Ahoy complex. The consultant was also requested to review the valuation report of DTZ Zadelhoff (DTZ) that had been submitted by the complainants before the initiation of the investigation [DZT’s ‘Taxatiereport’ valued the market level of rent for the Ahoy complex at EUR 3,9 million.], and to assess whether the profit-sharing arrangement stipulated in the lease between Ahoy Rotterdam NV and the municipality was consistent with the market. For all of these valuation reports, the consultant was requested to state a view on the correctness of the methodology applied.