48 VII. ASSESSMENT IN THE LIGHT OF THE STATE AID RULES State aid within the meaning of Article 87(1) of the EC Treaty › 2. Advantage › Economic advantage to the operator, Decision_act (EU) 2009/713

In forcesince 21 Oct 2008

The Commission has carried out its own in-depth assessment of these reports, and finds that Deloitte correctly applied the discounted cash flow method [The discounted cash flow (DCF) method is a commonly used method of valuing a project, company or asset by calculating the present value of a future cash flow, taking into account both the risk and the time expected to elapse before the cash is received.] to guide it in valuing the shares in Ahoy Rotterdam NV and the income approach to guide it in determining the rent for the complex. The Commission likewise finds that the reports correctly took into account the special features of the operating company that made it difficult to draw a proper comparison with other companies and transactions. Finally, the Commission finds that in its valuations Deloitte took proper account of the close link between the sale of the operation and the lease of the Ahoy complex. On the basis of its own assessment and of the findings of the independent consultant, the Commission takes the view that there are no reasonable grounds to challenge Deloitte’s reports.