40 VI. THE INDEPENDENT CONSULTANT’S STUDY, Decision_act (EU) 2009/713

In forcesince 21 Oct 2008

According to the consultant, the discrepancy between the valuations of the rent for the Ahoy complex arrived at by Deloitte and DTZ resulted from the different methods they had applied. The consultant approved of the approach taken by Deloitte [The consultant did not accept that the DTZ report provided a better indication, because in the consultant’s view the Ahoy complex could not be classed as ‘easily marketable’ (goed courant) and the methods used by DTZ were based on unclear comparisons and less appropriate or less developed assumptions.]. Underlining the close relation between Deloitte’s valuation of the shares in Ahoy Rotterdam NV and the determination of the rent for the complex, the independent consultant confirmed that given that Deloitte’s valuation of the shares was fair the method Deloitte had followed provided the most accurate estimate of the market level of the rent for the Ahoy complex.