VI. DOUBTS EXPRESSED BY THE COMMISSION IN INITIATING THE PROCEDURE, Decision_act (EU) 2005/137

In forcesince 15 Oct 2003
(30)

The Commission expressed doubts that Sogepa’s behaviour, even analysed in the overall context of its past investments, was equivalent to that of a private investor, for two types of reason:

a supposed private shareholder in Carsid would not be prepared to be alone in providing all the cash for the company’s new needs since the risks for the private shareholders and the public shareholder of Carsid could not be considered equivalent. The contribution of the private partners served no more than to move the productive plant within companies belonging to the group. The State, on the other hand, was putting up fresh money, with a new risk,

the expected return on the capital invested by the State in Carsid could not be considered to match the expectations of a private investor, since the return on such investment depended, on the one hand, on the situation of the firms involved in the project and, on the other, on developments in the steel industry at world, European and regional level.