Recital 66, Decision_act (EU) 2004/170

In forcesince 21 Oct 2003

As regards the precompetitive development activities, the Spanish authorities took the view that the model for engine design projects put forward by Pratt & Whitney was not necessarily the only one possible and that other OEMs were perfectly capable of adopting other models that might not coincide with the one described. In any event, according to the Spanish authorities, some major differences could be observed between the methods adopted by an OEM such as Pratt & Whitney and those of a firm like ITP. The proportion of precompetitive development tasks was, for one thing, much larger in the case of a supplier of subsystems than in that of an OEM since the former was involved not in engine marketing, certification or sales but in technical activities. The availability of existing technology (precedents) also differed as between a firm traditionally present in the market, like Pratt & Whitney, and a medium-sized firm that had been in the market for only 12 years, like ITP. For example, an OEM could regard a low-pressure turbine as a by-product of the high-pressure turbine, whereas ITP, a supplier of low-pressure turbines, could not refer to high-pressure turbine or any other previous turbine technology, and the net technological content of these activities was therefore proportionately higher in the case of ITP than for an OEM. Lastly, the Spanish authorities were convinced that the activities in respect of which the Commission had raised doubts did constitute precompetitive development activities for ITP, since they corresponded to the initial development of certain methodologies and processes.