As regards integrated logistic support activities for the AS900 project, the Commission took the view that these corresponded to marketable versions, to which they contributed no new feature, modification or improvement, and therefore did not form part of precompetitive development. The Spanish authorities explained that these activities related to the following aspects: (a) the illustration of technical manuals; (b) the drafting of technical manuals; and (c) reliability, maintenance, etc. The last-named activities, although carried out by the logistic support group, were design/development tasks, carried out at the same time as development of the turbine, which determined the product design itself. They did therefore constitute precompetitive development activities. As far as activities (a) and (b) were concerned, the Spanish authorities argued that the Commission's view could be justified if ITP were habitually engaged in activities of this type. However, in the present case, these were new activities for the company which introduced an innovation in the development of its methods, involving the development of tools necessary for the establishment of a new department. In particular, this included the development of systems and tools for producing and illustrating technical publications, which had to be drawn up in a manner that was compatible with those used for the aircraft as a whole and incorporate the latest available technological advances. A far from negligible share of the work therefore consisted in developing the successive prototypes and the final version of the systems for producing technical publications, a task which, according to the Spanish authorities, formed part of precompetitive development.
Admissibility of additional overheads and other operating expenses as eligible costs