The Spanish authorities understood that the Commission's doubts related to the costs under the heading "contribution to development of the programme". They could not understand why the Commission had classed these costs as additional overheads, since, in their view, they were in fact direct costs arising from the research activity. The Spanish authorities stressed that ITP was not an original engine manufacturer (OEM) and therefore could not, even if it so wished, assume responsibility for the engines as a whole and, in particular, for the process of incorporating its turbines into those engines. Consequently, the tasks involved in incorporating the turbine into the engine, and especially the tests on the turbine, had to be carried out under the responsibility of the OEM, with ITP's participation. The Spanish authorities also stressed that the intensity of the aid towards these eligible costs was 8 % and that the repayable advance requested for these costs accounted for 30 % of the total amount of the repayable advances requested for the entire project, which was in line with the conditions for intangible technology transfer costs associated with investment projects.
Incentive effect of the R & D component of the aid