The Spanish authorities considered that Pratt & Whitney's arguments concerning the aid intensity, in other words the link with aid received by Rolls-Royce for the Trent 500 project, were based on the incorrect assumption that Rolls-Royce was the only private shareholder in ITP and that the remaining shares belonged to the State or to regional or local authorities. But ITP was mainly privately owned, its only public shareholder being SEPI, which held 26,65 % of the capital. The remainder was split between the private companies Sener (26,65 %) and Rolls-Royce (46,7 %). Given its private company status, the state aid received by ITP in Spain was therefore separate from the aid granted by the United Kingdom to a British firm. The planned R & D aid to ITP corresponded to investments in capital, engineering and actual development equipment, for which no other state aid had been received. The conditions for ITP's entry into the project as a risk partner were furthermore market conditions, without any premium or special treatment by Rolls-Royce. There was no duplication of work or any overlap with aid granted in the United Kingdom. With regard to Pratt & Whitney's opinion that the Trent 500 was a derivative engine, the Spanish authorities pointed out that even a new engine was based on additional knowledge in relation to previous ones. That principle, which applied to all manufacturers, enabled each of them to reduce development costs significantly. In any event, the aid had to be assessed in relation to the actual development costs and not the costs that would have been incurred if the engine had been completely new. The Spanish authorities stressed that the aid was an incentive aimed at enabling ITP to enter a new area of activity and that ITP therefore did not have the experience acquired by other firms. As regards the level of innovation incorporated into the turbine, the Spanish authorities claimed that the design and the technology used were completely new in comparison with other low-pressure turbines produced by Rolls-Royce or any other manufacturer. They repeated that the aid to ITP was designed to cover costs that the company had genuinely incurred and had not been reduced in any way by state aid granted in the United Kingdom. Lastly, they took the view that it was not for them to comment on the accounting criteria used by Rolls-Royce and stressed that Rolls-Royce and ITP were two completely different companies.
Recital 64, Decision_act (EU) 2004/170
In forcesince 21 Oct 2003