Recital 40, Decision_act (EU) 2004/170

In forcesince 21 Oct 2003

With regard to the tools manufacturing activities, the Commission did not rule out the possibility that at least part of the tooling might be used for the series production of engines. The Spanish authorities acknowledged that one of the usual principles in a development programme was indeed to recover as many of the tools as possible for the production programme. However, in the present case, they claimed, the approach was different in that the project was based on extremely low purchase prices, which introduced huge risks with regard to the possibility of future manufacture. The time to market was furthermore reduced in order to be able to capture the three possible customers before competing projects. Lastly, the reduction of costs required from the outset made it necessary to introduce concepts that were unusual in this type of small engine, such as the reduction of the number of vanes, and therefore had to be verified at a very early stage in the project. It was therefore necessary to finalise the tooling very early on, even before the concepts had been demonstrated. The Spanish authorities also pointed out that, as a result of regional policy commitments, the cast components, which used to be produced in the United States, were to be transferred to Vizcaya, which meant that ITP had in any event to bear the cost of a new set of tools.