Recital 59, Decision_act (EU) 2004/170

In forcesince 21 Oct 2003

Pratt & Whitney shared the doubts raised by the Commission as to whether engine testing, certification and post-certification activities could be classed as precompetitive development activities within the meaning of the R & D framework. The company explained that, according to its own experience, large aero-engine development projects had four distinct phases:

–

the concept phase, during which market requirements, business strategy and technology readiness were continuously re-evaluated. Conceptual design studies were conducted with airframe manufacturers to determine the requirements for thrust, performance, weight, noise, emissions, installation constraints and so on. Technologies were proven through analysis and rig or engine testing in order to minimise technical risk. This phase could continue for long periods of time. It could be regarded as "precompetitive", but the costs were relatively low, about 4 % of the total programme cost,

–

the launch phase, during which the production design of a specific new engine model or derivative was developed. Some rig and component testing could be carried out, and long lead-time tooling and parts were ordered using the expected production configuration. By the end of this phase, the engine configuration and technology were largely fixed. The engine manufacturer entered into business agreements with customers, specifying the certification and delivery schedule, price, performance and technical requirements for the engine. This phase lasted around one year and accounted for some 9 % of the total programme development cost. Pratt & Whitney considered that this phase too could be regarded as precompetitive development within the meaning of the R & D framework, since it was uncertain until the end of the phase whether the engine would ever be manufactured and sold. However, by the end of the launch phase, if the programme was to proceed, it was because the engine manufacturer had obtained a sufficient number of orders, and subsequent phases could not therefore be deemed to constitute precompetitive activities,

–

the engine validation and certification phase, which was intended to establish that the product met specifications and was sufficiently safe and reliable for entry into service. New and unproven technologies were generally not added to the engine design during this phase since this would prove difficult, risky and costly. The phase could itself be divided into two parts: before and after production of the first engine to test (FETT), the initial prototype of the commercial production engine. During the production of the FETT, detailed design drawings of all engine components were completed. The FETT was typically fabricated by hand, using non-production processes and temporary tooling. The engine validation and certification phase prior to FETT lasted about one year after the end of the launch phase and accounted for around 9 % of the total programme cost. Once the FETT had been produced it had to successfully undergo all the tests required to ensure that the engine met all the minimum standards for safety and performance. All the engines used for these tests were produced in accordance with the design of the model to be certified. This period lasted about two years and accounted for around 55 % of total costs. A large proportion of these costs were incurred in producing the engines used for the tests. Five such engines could be enough for certifying a derivative engine, while as many as ten or more engines were normally necessary for a new engine design. These engines were usually manufactured using commercial production methods. They were tested under extreme conditions, which meant that it was practically impossible to refurbish and sell them to the airlines. They were therefore generally used for other development activities or in post-certification engine improvement programmes. Pratt & Whitney consequently shared the Commission's view that the costs incurred during this certification phase related to a product that could be used commercially - and which indeed was already sold commercially after the end of the launch phase,

–

the flight test and airframe certification phase, the final phase in which the engines were installed in the aircraft in accordance with the certified configuration. The aircraft had to successfully undergo a set of flight tests with the certified engines in order to demonstrate that the engine and airframe combination met the prescribed airworthiness, performance and operability requirements. After completing the flight test programme, flight test engines were typically refurbished and sold commercially. Along with the Commission, Pratt & Whitney took the view that the activities carried out during this phase could not be regarded as precompetitive development activities within the meaning of the R & D framework.