Recital 37, Decision_act (EU) 2004/170

In forcesince 21 Oct 2003

With regard to the high-thrust turbine project, the Commission did not rule out the possibility that the engine testing, certification and post-certification activities could relate to marketable products and might therefore not constitute precompetitive development activities. The Spanish authorities pointed out that the engine trials for this project comprised the following tests: extensometry, measurement of the metal temperatures, measurement of the air temperatures, thermal paints, efficiency tests, cycle tests, type tests and fan blade off tests. Only the last two were certification tests. According to the Spanish authorities, they were also crucial to the objective of developing the capacity of ITP's R & D department for designing complete models. The fan blade off test was not carried out earlier during the development phase in view of its high cost. It therefore provided the first opportunity (not without risk) for calibrating non-linear calculation tools developed for this loading case. The other activities formed part of the development process and constituted the initial verification and calibration of the design tools developed by ITP. The Spanish authorities furthermore took the view that components subjected to the tests could not be used commercially, given the ageing that accumulated during the resistance test (type test) and the destructive nature of the fan blade off test. Be that as it may, the Spanish authorities stated that this aspect could be checked by the monitoring committee provided for under the programme.