Recital 57, Decision_act (EU) 2004/170

In forcesince 21 Oct 2003

First, Pratt & Whitney argued that the intensity of the aid for this project should be considered in conjunction with state aid previously granted to Rolls-Royce for the Trent 500 engine and related development activities, since Rolls-Royce was the only private industrial partner in ITP. Account had to be taken in this connection of the fact that the Trent 500 was a derivative rather than a new engine and incorporated technologies taken from the Trent 700, Trent 800 and Trent 8104 engines, which meant that the costs and technological risks involved were reduced. Pratt & Whitney therefore took the view that the cost of developing the Trent 500 should be only 30 to 40 % of the cost of a completely new engine, a fact that should be taken into account when determining the eligible costs. The Trent 500 had furthermore already received state aid granted by the United Kingdom in 1998, which, according to Pratt & Whitney, must have been based on the assumption that Rolls-Royce would bear all the development costs. Transferring a share of the risks to other partners, such as ITP, would result in an effective increase in the intensity of the aid already granted and a "double-dipping" of state aid since those partners would obtain further state aid for themselves. There could even be "triple-dipping" of aid in that the request for additional aid presented by Rolls-Royce in 2001 for the Trent 600 and Trent 900 engines included, according to Pratt & Whitney, engine programmes and technologies that were already assisted by the 1997 aid grant. Pratt & Whitney also pointed out that Rolls-Royce's contribution to R & D activities from its own funds was unusually low compared with the levels of company-funded R & D by Pratt & Whitney and other competitors.