These three capital gains made on vessels deployed as part of the Corsican fleet had been charged by SNCM to the free network and other activities in the analytical accounts. It is true that this does not contravene the agreement between the OTC and SNCM, as the agreement does not provide for anything in this regard. However, even if the agreement has no provisions to this effect, the Commission is of the opinion that, from an economic standpoint, it is more appropriate to assign the capital gains from the cessation of an activity to the activity which sustained the investment costs, namely the Corsica network. Indeed, the vessels in question, whose priority use was to provide the public service(53), were purchased and fully depreciated over the period covered by the agreement. Thus the financing and depreciation of the vessels was borne entirely by the public service. For this reason, the Commission's general conclusion, based on the opinion of its expert's as to overcompensation, must take account of this correction.
Absence of overcompensation