The German authorities and the other interested parties also claim, even taking account of the present value of deferred taxation, that the overall gain from deferring payment of tax is not greater, using the Article 82f mechanism, than the gain produced by accelerated depreciation. Even if this is accepted to be true this argument takes no account of the enormous flexibility provided by the provisions of Article 82f. It is not always in companies' interests to opt for accelerated depreciation, especially companies running at a loss. Whereas the choice of accelerated or straight-line depreciation is made solely on acquisition of the asset, the special depreciation facility provided for in Article 82f can be employed at any time during the first five years following acquisition, and that is the real advantage of Article 82f compared with the systems of accelerated depreciation or, even more so, straight-line depreciation. This flexibility of use enables beneficiary airlines, for example, to make changes more readily in the management of their fleets. It permits them above all to increase the amount of depreciation at their discretion during highly profitable years. By juggling the depreciation provisions in this way between profit and loss-making years, companies cannot only spread but also reduce their taxable income and even cut out any taxation in some cases. Whilst German tax law allows companies to carry over indefinitely their losses to subsequent profit-making years it does not always authorize profits to be carried over to any future loss-making years. These can only be set against the non-distributed profits of the two previous years to an amount of DM 10 million. At the end of the day the advantages derived by companies through Article 82f, which introduces an extra possibility of depreciation in addition to accelerated and straight-line depreciation, cannot be denied.
The German authorities and other interested parties further claim that the method of depreciation provided for by Article 82f is a general measure of German tax law and that it is inseparable from the German tax system as a whole. It can therefore be examined only on the basis of Article 101 of the Treaty as part of harmonization at Community level and not on the basis of Articles 92 and 93 of the Treaty.