, Decision_act (EU) 1996/369

In force

Under Article 92 (1) of the Treaty and Article 61 (1) of the Agreement on the European Economic Area, aid granted by the States or by means of State resources in any form whatsoever which distorts or threatens to distort competition by favouring certain companies or certain products is incompatible with the common market and with the Agreement to the extent that it affects trade between Member States and between the contracting parties.

In this case the special depreciation facility provided for by Article 82f of the Einkommensteuerdurchführungsverordnung enables beneficiary companies, where certain conditions are met, to reduce the amount of their taxable income and thereby the amount of tax that would normally be due any given year without recourse to these provisions. It therefore provides the beneficiary companies with a financial advantage the cost of which is directly borne by the budget of the German State.

The German authorities and two of the other interested parties claim that use of this special depreciation scheme does not have the effect of cancelling payment of the tax to the amount of the respective depreciation provision but simply of deferring it. However, as with the system of accelerated depreciation, the advantage gained in applying Article 82f is precisely the fact of deferring payment of tax. Whilst at the end of the period of depreciation of an asset the sum of the nominal amounts of tax paid to the German inland revenue over that period is identical regardless of the method of depreciation employed the same cannot be said of the sum of the present value of this tax which takes account of interest rates. All things being equal, in the final analysis the net financial advantage arising out of using accelerated depreciation or the Article 82f mechanism is indeed real, compared with straight-line depreciation, for companies making profits, even if this advantage is less than it seems at first sight.