Following initiation of the procedure, Germany, by letters of 24 January 1994 (communication of 19 January 1994) and 28 February 1994 (communication of 18 February 1994), and four other interested parties, namely, Airbus Industrie, the British airline British Midland, the German association Arbeitsgemeinschaft Deutscher Luftfahrt-Unternehmen (ADL) and the German company Hapag-Lloyd Fluggesellschaft mbH, submitted comments. Airbus Industrie refers to aid given to the American aeronautical industry through the system of 'foreign sales corporation` and recommends that the Commission exercise the utmost prudence in this matter. British Midland takes the view that Article 82f tax measure constitutes aid which is incompatible with the common market because of the edge it gives German carriers in the liberalized Community market for civil aviation. In contrast, the German Government and the two other interested parties claim that the measure in question does not amount to aid within the meaning of Article 92 (1) of the Treaty and that it should, in any case, benefit from the derogation provided for by points (b) and (c) of Article 92 (3). They put forward several arguments in this connection, including some previously set out by the German Government, which can be summarized as follows:
similar aid arrangements exist in other Member States. Consequently, the Commission cannot act against one Member State without violating the principle of equality,
similar arrangements also exist in non-Community countries, in particular the United States, and the Committee of Wise Men set up by the Commission in 1993 specifically proposed measures to promote the accelerated depreciation of aircraft in the Member States to enable Community airlines to combat competition from airlines from non-Community countries,
it is not an established fact that the measure distorts competition and affects trade between the Member States since it does not improve the position of German airlines on the Community market. Furthermore, compared with the systems in other Member States, the German tax system is, on the whole, not favourable to the companies,