, Decision_act (EU) 1996/369

In force

It should be noted that the provisions of Article 82f apply not only to aircraft but also, with less restrictive conditions than for aircraft, to merchant ships and fishing boats. The report to the Bundestag of 11 November 1991 concludes that the system is a good investment incentive in that it enables airlines to avoid excessive fluctuations in their financial results and tax liability. The report puts the annual tax saving to beneficiary airlines and shipping companies as a whole at DM 10 million. However, the German authorities have not been able to give a breakdown of this figure between the various companies concerned.

In the maritime sector the provisions of Article 82f have so far been covered by the Community guidelines on aid to shipbuilding. The last decision taken in this respect by the Commission (for 1995) dates back to 1 March 1995 and was sent to the German authorities on 6 March 1995 (Case N 641/93).

II

By letter of 21 April 1993 the Commission, acting on the basis of Article 93 (1) of the Treaty, informed the German Government that in its opinion the Article 82f special depreciation scheme amounted to fiscal aid affecting trade between the Member States and distorting competition within the common market. The letter was published in the Official Journal of the European Communities (1). It also found that this aid could not be regarded as compatible with the common market by virtue of Article 92 (2) and (3) of the Treaty. The Commission therefore proposed in that same letter that the German authorities should discontinue the aid, in the civil aviation sector only, by 1 January 1994 at the latest. In the absence of information showing that the aid in question is compatible with the common market, the Commission also pointed out to the German authorities that it reserved the right to initiate the procedure laid down in Article 93 (2) of the Treaty. The case has been registered under number E 4/93.