, Decision_act (EU) 1996/369

In force
–

the special depreciation scheme in question does not give companies any advantage over straight-line or accelerated depreciation systems. In particular, the total amount depreciated is identical and the budget of the German State does not, in the final analysis, suffer any reduction in tax revenue since payment of the tax is simply deferred,

–

Article 82f, which has similar effects to accelerated depreciation, is a general measure of German tax law,

–

Article 82f is an inseparable part of the general German tax system and the Commission cannot call it into question by virtue of provisions governing State aid in the absence of tax harmonization at Community level, which in this instance would mean invoking Article 101 of the Treaty,

–

the measure aims to protect the environment and promote civil aviation and the aeronautical industry in the Community by encouraging the purchase of new, less polluting aircraft.

The observations of the other interested parties have been brought to the knowledge of the German Government, which commented on them by letter to the Commission of 3 May 1994.

The German Government also submitted further comments in this matter by letters of 11 August 1994, 12 January 1995 (communication of 18 October 1994), 2 February 1995 and 4 October 1995 (communication of 28 September 1995).

LEGAL ASSESSMENT

IV

On the extension of the measure in question up to 31 December 1994

Extension of the validity of the provisions of Article 82f up to 31 December 1994 for civil aviation, which led first of all to a proposal for appropriate measures and then to initiation of this procedure, amounts to existing aid within the meaning of Article 93 (1) of the Treaty. A final decision by the Commission with regard to existing aid takes effect only from the date of its adoption. Therefore, given that no final decision from the Commission was forthcoming in this matter before 31 December 1994, the procedure, which has become devoid of purpose, should be closed.

The result is that the German companies concerned can apply Article 82f as regards their taxable income for 1994, as declared in 1995.

V

On the extension of the measure in question from 1 January 1995 to 31 December 1999